Cooking With Janica
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • TikTok
All Recipes
Copycat
Instant Pot
Fried
Dog Treats
Recipe Filter
All Recipes
Copycat
Instant Pot
Fried
Dog Treats
Recipe Filter
Home / Blog / Drinks / Cocktails

Best Whiskey for an Old Fashioned

This site runs ads and generates income from affiliate links. Read my disclosure policy.


  • Share

  • Tweet
Jessica Pinney Avatar

Author

Jessica Pinney

Published

Jul. 21, 2022

Updated

Mar. 5, 2024
Five different bottles of whiskey are on a black background.

On Old Fashioned is one of the best whiskey cocktails, in my humble opinion. It’s a relatively simple drink that combines whiskey, sugar, and bitters. Because the spirit is the main ingredient, the whiskey you choose can make or break it!

I’ve done the super hard work and tedious research of trying dozens of different whiskeys in our old fashioned drinks so you don’t have to!

We compiled the short list below of our absolute favorites to use in everything from an apple old fashioned, to a peach old fashioned, or even our Christmas old fashioned recipe. 

#1 – Double Oaked Woodford Reserve Bourbon

A bottle of Woodford Reserve Double Baked bourbon on a black background.

Bourbon is always my first choice. Woodford Reserve double oaked has been aged nine extra months from their standard bourbon. The result is an ultra smooth, rich, buttery flavor that creates a luxurious old fashioned cocktail. 

#2 – Michter’s Straight Rye Whiskey

A bottle of Michter's Single Barrel Straight Rye Whiskey on a black background.

Michter’s is my go to when I desire a rye old fashioned. This whiskey has a lot of notes – citrus, pepper, oak, cherry, and butterscotch to a name a few. All of them come together beautifully to make a rich and flavorful old fashioned.

#3 – Basil Hayden

A Basil Hayden whiskey bottle on a black background.

Basil Hayden has a moderate ABV, which makes it perfect for new whiskey drinkers. It’s very light bodied and is a great spirit choice for anyone seeking an easy to sip old fashioned.

#4 – Buffalo Trace Bourbon

A bottle of Buffalo Trace Bourbon on a black background.

Another great bourbon option is Buffalo Trace. It’s widely available and sold at a great price point. It’s perfect with those who are looking for a budget-friendly whiskey that still has a great taste.

#5 – High West Rye

A bottle of High West Double Rye Whiskey on a black background.

High West Double Rye is a blend of two ryes – one that is bold and one that is spicy. The result is a bold and complex whiskey that is perfect when you want an old fashioned with lots of flavor notes. 

  • Share
  • Tweet

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Subscribe via Email

to stay in the loop on new posts!

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Loading

Browse Around

appetizers
side dishes
chicken
breakfast
drinks
desserts

Popular Posts


  • Red Bull Italian Soda

    Red Bull Italian Soda


  • Starbucks Iced Caramel Macchiato Recipe

    Starbucks Iced Caramel Macchiato Recipe


  • Irish Trash Can Recipe

    Irish Trash Can Recipe


  • Copycat Taco Bell Quesadilla Recipe

    Copycat Taco Bell Quesadilla Recipe


  • Best Pimento Cheese Recipe

    Best Pimento Cheese Recipe


  • Wine Gummy Bears Recipe (Red, White, & Rosé)

    Wine Gummy Bears Recipe (Red, White, & Rosé)


  • Yogurt Peanut Butter Banana Dog Treats Recipe

    Yogurt Peanut Butter Banana Dog Treats Recipe


  • Homemade Crunchwrap Supreme Recipe

    Homemade Crunchwrap Supreme Recipe

Game Day


  • Crock Pot Taco Dip

    Crock Pot Taco Dip


  • Jalapeno Popper Cheese Ball

    Jalapeno Popper Cheese Ball


  • Smoked Queso

    Smoked Queso


  • Cherry Coke Smoked Pork Shoulder

    Cherry Coke Smoked Pork Shoulder


  • Buffalo Chicken Tenders Recipe

    Buffalo Chicken Tenders Recipe


  • Smoked Hamburgers & Hot Dogs Recipe

    Smoked Hamburgers & Hot Dogs Recipe

Coffee


  • Sakura Latte

    Sakura Latte


  • Butterbeer Latte

    Butterbeer Latte


  • Iced Sugar Cookie Latte

    Iced Sugar Cookie Latte


  • Pumpkin Spice Frappuccino

    Pumpkin Spice Frappuccino


  • Caramel Apple Cold Brew Coffee

    Caramel Apple Cold Brew Coffee


  • Caipirinha Coffee Cocktail Recipe

    Caipirinha Coffee Cocktail Recipe

Collections


Copycat
Dehydrated
Dog Treats
Healthy
Roundups

Courses


Appetizers
Breakfast
Desserts
Dinner
Side Dishes

Drinks


All Drinks
Coffee
Cocktails
Non-Alcoholic
Shots

Types


Bread
Pizza
Sandwiches
Sauces
Soup

Methods


Air Fryer
Crock Pot
Fried
Grilling
Instant Pot

Proteins


Beef
Chicken
Pork
Seafood
Turkey

Holidays


All Holidays
Christmas
Game Day
Halloween
Thanksgiving
About
Contact
Work with Us
Disclosure

© All Rights Reserved. Theme by OC.